There are critical, pivotal moments in any liberation or decolonization movement when the new replaces the old. The Stonewall Rebellion in 1969, which ignited the Gay Liberation Revolution of 1970 and thereafter, represented such a historically monumental turning point in United States history. In August of 1970, another important forward-moving pivotal moment occurred in San Francisco when radical left elements of the early Gay Liberation and Lesbian Feminist movements, which were rapidly growing in strength, disrupted and commandeered the national convention of the North American Conference of Homophile Organizations (NACHO). This event marked the end of the Homophile period (1953-1970) in U.S. LGBTQ history that was founded and largely centered in Los Angeles.
Initially in this article, as always, historical context is useful to understand the importance of the NACHO takeover. My lifetime study of LGBTQ history in Los Angeles, a city that is often called the cradle of gay history in the U.S., as well as national LGBTQ history, leads to an overview of four periods to that historical narrative in L.A.:
- Mattachine (1950-1953): Gay and lesbian people for the first time discussed their oppression with each other, for the first time identified as a minority group, and operated in an organized, private manner that was highly participatory, radical in intention, and centered in L.A.
- Homophile (1953-1970): Was conservative, assimilationist, emancipationist, law reformist with important, pioneering printing of magazines and increased public visibility, and centered in L.A. Continued educating about gay and lesbian oppression (although the word “oppression” was hardly ever used, “discrimination” instead). The term “homophile,” meaning “same-sex love,” moved identity forward from hetero supremacy’s purely sexual definition to also include an affectional, relational dimension.
- Gay Liberation (1969-85): The Gay Big Bang. Was a revolutionary, militant, gay- and lesbian-centered, and grassroots mass movement that seized liberation through civil disobedience, created visible, organized communities from the bottom up, fought back against hetero supremacy assertively and proactively, and unleashed a theretofore largely underground gay culture.
- Neo-Homophile (1985-present): Is conservatively liberal, assimilationist, law reformist and electoral politics-centered, characterized by elite capture based on wealth, privilege, and race from the top down with the marginalization of the rest of the community, and centered in West Hollywood and elsewhere in L.A. and in large cities in the U.S.
The jury is still out on the possibilities of queer militancy. At this point, many queers appear to be being assimilated into elite capture, however, since there is almost no local news coverage and zero investigative reportage by the LGBTQ media today, hopefully that initial observation might not be correct over time.
The following historical account is rarely reported because it happened on the West Coast. Gay historical writing is often skewed toward the East Coast, particularly New York City, presenting a distorted historical picture of what actually happened—the gay historical dimension of an often noted, much larger cultural critique of one-sidedness toward the East Coast on many cultural fronts. The following historical rendering is in the tradition of Howard Zinn and his influential, progressive A People’s History of the United States (1980) with a bottom-up narrative rather than top-down orientation.
What Was NACHO?
NACHO—the North American Conference of Homophile Organizations—was founded in 1966 as a coordinating organization for the handful of small homophile organizations in the U.S. and Canada that were organized in the 1950s and 1960s, branching out over North America in an important network at that time from a Los Angeles center. Foster Gunnison, Jr., one of the founders of NACHO, stated the organization was formed to safeguard the Homophile effort from being taken over by “fringe elements, beatniks, and other professional non-conformists”—people like the politically radicalized younger people of the early, revolutionary Gay Liberation movement.

GLF Call to Action. Berkeley Barb, August 1970.
While NACHO originally possessed much possibility as an umbrella organization, that potential never materialized due to NACHO’s heated internecine power struggles over membership, voting rights, lesbian equality, and credentialing at virtually every annual conference, as well as its conservative, conformist, and assimilationist ideology and practices that were becoming anachronistic given the revolutionary zeitgeist percolatingthroughout the U.S. a year after Stonewall.
How Did Gay Liberation Takeover Happen?
That fateful “gunfight” at the homo corral, what a Gay Liberation newspaper at the time in San Francisco, Gay Sunshine, correctly identified as “the battle that ended the homophile movement,” occurred at the annual NACHO conference in the organizational space of the Society for Individual Rights (SIR), a homophile group at 83 Sixth St. in San Francisco on August 25-28, 1970. Paradoxically, the militant first National Student Gay Liberation Conference had concluded in the same SIR meeting space just a few days before the NACHO conference started.
Thirty official voting delegates from homophile organizations attended the NACHO conference, four of whom were women. Racial and class composition is hard to determine, but, given the times, it was probably white with bourgeois pretensions. A Black photographer for KQED in San Francisco quipped to S.F. GLF member Leo Lawrence, “It looks like an American Legion convention.” There were also numerous “official observers.” And then, as never before experienced by NACHO, angry, uninvited Gay Liberationists showed up, demanding radical change and militant action. Probably, at any given time, the attendance ebbed and flowed with about 50-80 people in attendance.

Jim Kepner (left) and Dorr Legg, official ONE, Inc. delegates to NACHO conference in S.F. in 1970. They are standing in front of the doorway to ONE, Inc., then located on the second floor at 2256 Venice Blvd. in L.A. ONE, Inc. was the cornerstone organization of the Homophile effort.
Official delegates at the conference representing L.A. Homophile groups were Dorr Legg and Jim Kepner of ONE, Inc. and the Metropolitan Community Church’s Rev. Troy Perry, who also served as chair of Western NACHO. Cheri Matisse and Morris Kight, representing L.A. GLF, were official observers, and Sandy Blixton, from GLF in Venice, attended with no official designation. Michael Itkin from New York City attended as an official observer representing New York City’s Gay Liberation newspaper, Come Out!
On August 25, 1970, in hopes of pacifying the coming revolutionary storm, the beginning date of the conference, the official opening meeting of the conference was delayed a day, in order for lesbian feminists and gay liberationists to address NACHO delegates. Del Martin, co-founder of the Daughters of Bilitis, Cheri Matisse of L.A. GLF, and other women decried the sexism in NACHO and demanded that the organization, focused primarily on gay men’s issues, give equal attention to lesbian concerns. Matisse, criticizing NACHO’s conservative political approach, screamed, “You can’t ask for your rights, you have to TAKE them.” Kight gave a warmly received speech about understanding each other and then immediately returned to L.A. to attend the LAPD restraining order hearing requested by L.A. GLF in federal court.
The gay liberationists supported the women’s protest and demanded that the conference be opened up so that anyone present could vote and that NACHO officially endorse the Black Panthers (Huey Newton, the leader of the Black Panthers, had issued his statement that August supporting Gay Liberation as a legitimate revolutionary movement) and Women’s and Gay Liberation movements as well, and radically change NACHO’s politically conservative law reform agenda and ineffective emancipist mode of operation. Homophiles beseeched the dominant hetero supremacist power structure, “Accept us! We are just like you.” GLF protesters shouted, “We must liberate ourselves and our people! We are self-accepting gay and lesbian people.”
For two subsequent days at the conference, reported by one gay liberationist, Jim Rankin, as “terrible, joyous days of open, honest conflict,” chaos, confusion, performative posturing, and much legitimate political debate took over, with NACHO in a losing, defensive battle with the type of gay men and lesbians that the organization had never directly encountered previously. At the opening night banquet, for example, Itkin and Tom Sweiger from New York City took off their clothes and ate in the nude. Franklin Kameny of Mattachine in Washington, D.C., Rev. Perry, Legg, Kepner, and other accredited homophile delegates accused Gay Liberation and other radicals of trying to steamroll the conference, which was true, but with the intention of either making NACHO relevant to the social revolutions occurring across the U.S. or else replacing NACHO.
[There is confusion in the use of the term “Mattachine.” Harry Hay, who was central to the founding of the original Mattachine, always differentiated, correctly, between what he called the “First Mattachine,” 1950-1953, which was politically radical in intention, and the “Second Mattachine,” 1953-1970, which was moved in 1953 to San Francisco by Hal Call where it became a conservative homophile organization. New York Mattachine, Washington, D.C., Mattachine (Kameny’s organization), and other groups using that name after 1953 should be viewed as conservative Second Mattachine homophile organizations.]
The Last Day Takeover by Gay Liberation
The climactic scene of the overthrow of the Homophile era occurred on the last day of the conference.
Theretofore, the Gay Liberationists largely occupied the foyer of the SIR meeting space, while the official delegates and observers gathered in the main meeting space with the entrance to the meeting space blocked with a pile of desks and a hired guard to keep GLF and other radicals out. At 3 p.m., a few hours before the conference was to end that fateful, final day, someone in the foyer yelled “Let’s go!” and about 30 Gay Liberationists forced their way into the NACHO meeting space by dismantling the barricade.
Many official delegates fled the room, but there were a few NACHO allies of Gay Liberation who remained. SIR’s Larry Littlejohn and Rev. Perry threatened to call the police to have the militants arrested. When it became obvious their threats were not working, Littlejohn and Perry disappeared from the room. Although pandemonium occurred, an undercurrent of order also prevailed. Blixton, from Los Angeles, and Itkin, from New York City, pressed for a resolution, which was passed and took effect immediately, stating that everyone present was a member of NACHO with voting privileges. Itkin then took the podium with several resolutions that passed that fateful day with everyone voting. The newly liberated NACHO endorsed the Gay Liberation and Women’s Liberation movements as well as the Black Panthers, called for immediate withdrawal of the U.S. military from the Vietnam War, demanded an official investigation of how many gay people were killed in Nazi concentration camps during the Second World War, and approved a provision that would allow any military member wishing to leave the Armed Forces to do so with an honorable discharge.
Rarely in history does one historical era end and a new radical, revolutionary period begin with such a clear demarcation as was accomplished at the 1970 NACHO gathering that August in San Francisco. Homophile organizations gradually faded away as the Gay Liberation revolutionary drumbeat was heard and responded to across the country and then around the world. ONE, Inc. in L.A.—Homophile Central—limped on for several years, becoming an empty shell of its former self, although its Sunday afternoon lecture series continued to be a relevant part of the community’s intellectual life until Dorr Legg’s death in 1994, marking the end of a life well spent in service to LGBTQ people.

Rev. Troy Perry in 1970, an official NACHO delegate from the Metropolitan Community Church in L.A. that called itself then “the church of the homophile community.”
Both the Mattachine and Homophile periods (1950-1970) were important in waking up gay and lesbian resistance (although never called “resistance” then) and deserve honored respect for their courageous and pioneering efforts. Both would fit what historians of liberation and decolonization movements many times label “secondary resistance,” meaning educating about and raising the consciousness of a people about their oppression, although homophiles would never use that liberation language. Gay Liberation would represent “primary resistance,” the actual liberation of gay and lesbian people by directly and immediately fighting back against hetero supremacy to remove the oppressor’s power and control over them. Both types of resistance are necessary for any type of successful liberation or decolonization movement.
Rev. Troy Perry in 1970, an official NACHO delegate from the Metropolitan Community Church in L.A. that called itself then “the church of the homophile community.”[/caption]Rev. Perry returned to Los Angeles, changed by the flameout of the Homophile effort in San Francisco. On his return, even though he remained somewhat conservative in his thinking and fit in seamlessly later with the neo- homophiles (1985-present), he became more activist in his approach to the struggles of gay and lesbian people in the early 1970s and played an important role in the evolution of the LGBTQ community, particularly in its Christian religion sector. The roots of MCC/Rev. Perry and Gay Liberation, however, came out of different places in history. Rev. Perry appeared through the doorway of Evangelical Christianity and was influenced by the Homophile effort, particularly SIR in San Francisco. The roots of Gay Liberation are the Stonewall Rebellion and the revolutionary tsunami released thereafter through the Gay Liberation mass movement. Nevertheless, from the beginning of Gay Liberation, I have always respected Rev. Perry and his work over the decades and consider him a valued pioneer brother who was there when there were only a handful cleaving a clearing in the hetero supremacy forest.
What Must Happen Now?
The small conservative Homophile effort was replaced by a Gay Liberation mass movement, which emerged out of the social revolutions happening everywhere in the 1960s and 1970s in the U.S. That movement liberated and transformed the lives of gay and lesbian people everywhere. Since 1985, the relatively conservative Neo-Homophile ideology and values, which grew more out of the so-called Reagan Revolution than the Gay Liberation Revolution, dominates the LGBTQ community today. Younger, progressive queer men and women are urgently summoned for a new social change effort to politically revivify and radically transform LGBTQ communities in a united, participatory, forward-moving, and evolving direction.
Today there is no shortage of LGBTQ performative flapping jaws on screens as political entertainers and influencers. Scarcity comes from intellectual analysis and spiritual consciousness with organized feet-on-the-ground leading LGBTQ people forward, crucially remembering, it always starts with an organized few, not tens of thousands.
I hopefully scan the queer horizon carefully searching for signs of such a critical revival and participatory movement, but first the queer generation needs to honestly and courageously ask itself, “How am I oppressed as a queer person today?” Everything depends on the answer to that question. Action grows out of oppression. Otherwise, complacency and collaboration with the current LGBTQ Neo-Homophile status quo and elite capture will continue to rule. Or, as William Faulkner succinctly put it in Requiem for a Nun, “The past is never dead. It’s not even past.”
