Gay Acceptance

Elite Capture and a Constructive Way Forward for the LGBTQ Community in LA (and Everywhere Else)

September 18, 2023

An essential question for progressives today, as always, is: How to put our insightful words into engaged action? My favorite way of saying it is: How do we get our lips and feet moving in the same direction? The Christian Mass exhorts people “to be Doers of the Word, not Hearers only.” And so, it goes.

A 2020 article periodized the history of the L.A. gay community which is often referred to as “the cradle of American gay history”:

  • Mattachine Period (1951-1953): Organized, secret, talking with each other, suggested a unique homo culture, radical beginnings.
  • Homophile Period (1953-1969): Conservative, assimilation, hetero acceptance through hetero imitation, pioneer publishing.
  • Gay Liberation Period (1969-early 1990s): The Big Bang: Revolution through self-acceptance, political consciousness-raising, liberation via militancy, grassroots community-building.
  • Neo-Homophile Period (late 1990s-present): Assimilation, hetero imitation, moderate-conservative electoral politics,

A recent essay analyzed the phenomenology of power in the LGBTQ community in L.A., and everywhere else, during the past 70 years based on the framework of Olufemi O. Taiwo’s Elite Capture: How the Powerful Took Over Identity Politics (And Everything Else). The important question is: How does the LGBTQ community in L.A., and everywhere else, constructively move forward beyond Elite Capture?

Dreams of the Young and Visions of the Elders

Michael Meade, imprisoned Vietnam War resister, urban healer, storyteller extraordinaire stated immensely important words when he wrote:

  • “An old idea suggests that the only ones more idealistic than young people are the elders. It’s not that the elders naively believe that the great ideals of humanity, peace and justice, healing and compassion, are simply attainable. Rather the idea is that without a commitment to such ideals a culture simply collapses into political infighting and economic warfare.”
  • “Another old idea suggests that a culture falls apart when the dreams of its youth are rejected and visions of its elders are neglected. This country is moving closer to the kind of lack of vision and lack of knowledge that precipitates such a fall.”

Through dialogues with increasing numbers of LGBTQ youth— sometimes for an eldering moment and sometimes eldering for years—I have experienced intelligent, politically aware, spiritually alive, extremely creative, and idealistic queer young people out there whose lives are not simply reduced to a Tik-Tok level of discourse. Malidoma Some often quipped, “Young people tell the truth because they haven’t learned how to pretend yet.”

With the L.A. LGBTQ community in the chokehold of Elite Capture, in many ways death to gay spirit, it is vitally important at this time in our evolution as LGBTQ people that queer youth begin talking their dreams out loud so those aspirations can be heard by adults and elders who want to support and encourage them.

Young queers, sing your dreams forward into life. You should be able to articulate your oppression in a society and world in which hetero supremacy thrives, using the experiences and language of your generation and the organizing tools available to you. But act, act, act. Organize, organize, organize. Serve, serve, serve. You must pour your hearts and souls into it. And there are 101 ways to be distracted.

Remember, depending on which hetero supremacist is in command, Artificial Intelligence could easily lay out a how-to-do-it plan on eliminating LGBTQ people. Perhaps, such a plan has already been created. I’m not a conspiracy theorist. There is a ubiquitous history of and today support for such a gay genocide in many places in the world.

Come Out

oung Exuberance of Gay Liberation, New York City, 1970 (Photograph: Peter Hujar)

Also remember, the Gay Liberation revolution did not begin with masses of people. In 1969, in L.A., there were a mere handful of mostly young people talking about gay oppression and liberation together and together dreaming their dream forward into life through organizing and direct action—then a room full of people, followed by a street full, then a gay and lesbian critical mass.

Just as young queers are encouraged to speak the budding truth of their dreams, elders must likewise share their ripening visions with the young. Everything depends on this deeper coming out—the transmission of intergenerational idealism, knowledge and wisdom, a two-way street.

In 2020, after writing about the four periods of gay history in L.A. referenced above, I envisioned what a fifth period, a Queer Liberation period, by that name or another, might look like. Allow me to speak that envisioning again for the young and late comers.

“Prologue: An Envisioning

My rich imagination and abundant altruism, however, envision a fifth historical period.

The Queer Liberation Period (2020-2050): A Revolution in Political Consciousness, Community, and Identity

As a result of the Black Lives Matter Rebellion in May and June 2020, fueled largely by young people, the L.A. LGBTQ community awoke from its Neo-Homophile slumber. A younger generation of leadership emerged, representing the colors in the rainbow and socioeconomic possibilities. A political and cultural sea change took place.

The Queer Liberation period was characterized by a new, radical political consciousness, modeled by BLM, in which the wimpy, psychological nomenclature, “homophobia,” of the mid-20th century was replaced by a more societally astute, 21stcentury understanding of queer oppression by their adoption of the term “systemic and institutionalized heterosexual supremacy”—"hetero supremacy” for short.

The word “queer,” which in the early 21st century had an amorphous, superficial quality to it, was infused by Queer Liberation with powerful political and cultural meaning that carried forward-moving gravitas and the smell of revolution.

Concrete demands were made on the political system at all levels based on the real needs of gay and lesbian people—affordable housing, decent paying jobs, accessible quality education, affordable health care—rather than photo ops of Neo-Homophile politicians and their sycophants and being a cash cow for both political parties.

A keen desire arose for older forms of participatory community. Politically aware, queer, young people and others, active in social change movements elsewhere, returned to queer community organizing, creating a community ethos that called for assuming responsibility for each other, meaning everyone—a community where, as John Lewis put it, “no one will be left out or left behind.”

Age-apartheid gradually died out and vital intergenerational dialogue and cooperation thrived between the Queer Liberation generation and those who went before. This benefitted Queer Liberation because they knew from dialogues with their elders not to become distracted by white racist tokenism and by the hollow lip service of corporations and politicians who claimed verbally to support critically needed, structural changes in society. Queer Liberation kept its eye on the prize. Their only litmus test for “the talkers” was: Do their lips and feet move in the same direction.

Historians dubbed the Queer era as “a renaissance in queer-centered community building”—new community-based institutions and cultural venues thrived. The mass entertainment, rainbow credit cards, and shallow celebrity culture of the Neo-Homophile era faded away. In L.A., a new generation built the world’s first Queer Community Cultural and Performing Arts Center which became a generator of queer creativity and an exciting model for communities globally.

After years of militant attacks and confrontations by Queer Liberation, the Catholic Church was forced to rescind its dogma that queer people were “intrinsically morally disordered,” a victory as important as Gay Liberation’s 1973 victory over the mental health industry.

Shortly thereafter, Pope Francis and sixteen Cardinals announced publicly they were queer. Other religions followed close behind, apologizing for the grave violence and harm their teachings had caused.

A queer community mosque, where everyone was welcomed, opened in South L.A. led by a queer imam. In North Hollywood, a Hindu Temple flourished with truly queer priests and spirit-intoxicated queer youth danced in ecstasy rather than on it. Shamanic drumming circles facilitated shamanic healing ceremonies all over the city aimed at maintaining the spiritual health and well-being of the queer and larger communities.

Community alliances were made with other militant social change and progressiveefforts in the U.S. that ended thirty years of Neo Homophile insularity. At the same time, Queer Liberation also became a dynamic and militant international movement with important political and cultural breakthroughs around the world led by local queer leaders and communities, particularly in China, Russia, Africa and Islamic world. No queer person anywhere was alone anymore. Being queer was no longer a death sentence.

After clawing it away from West Hollywood, WeHo Pride was reclaimed by the community and became a Los Angeles-based, grassroots Queer Freedom Day march again. Due to an expansive and inclusive political queer consciousness, the march was relocated to DTLA—the center of L.A. where East meets West and North meets South—and floats honoring Stonewall and noteworthy ancestors replaced anachronistic corporate ones.

During the Queer Liberation era, the visual culture hamster-wheel slowed down enough that face-to-face queer history and culture courses flourished in the community and an intellectual awakening occurred. Intelligent, young queer people no longer had to dumb it down to be accepted in the community. Queer visual and literate cultures became a both/and reality.

As a result of this intellectual awakening and widespread Queer Liberation consciousness-raising, the outdated assimilation/sexual orientation model of identity was replaced by a deeper, contemporary, existential understanding shaped by queer empirical experience and corroborated by evolutionary and sociobiology. It was called an essentialist/social contribution model of queer identity.”

Elite Capture and A Constructive Way Forward

After a lifetime of grassroots gay community organizing of one type or another, much learning one way or another, blessed personal failures and flaws, much listening and dialoguing, dodging the bullet, and tons of self-reflection, I say, particularly to queer young people under age 40, there is a way forward beyond Elite Capture.

Forward, embracing a larger understanding of what it means to be gay-queer and having the courage to act like a spiritual warrior. Remember, try to remember: A warrior acts, only a fool reacts. If there is a problem, come up with a constructive solution and act on it.

Here is a suggestion forward, not the last words on the subject, but perhaps a few first words.

Idealism in Action: A Radically Revisioned Community Consciousness Through Coalition.

As Michael Meade wrote, without idealists a society implodes.

First, I invite you to consider an alchemical framework that will be useful. Such ideas may be new to many LGBTQ people. To many progressives, elites and others, it will also be new which is the purpose of this essay. Alchemy is the art and science of transformation with a rich history in European, Chinese, Islamic cultures among others. Very simply put, alchemy involves a series of unions and separations of opposites that over time can result in a higher level of consciousness, daily functioning and wellbeing for individuals and a society.

Usually, the holding of two opposites at one time—left-right, grassroots-elite capture, individual-collective, light-dark—causes great tension in an individual and a society, resulting in that tension being resolved by “either/or” retreat rather than “both/and” progress.

“The Mystery of the Bridal Chamber” were the poetic words used by medieval European alchemists to describe a “both/and” awareness —two becoming one. “And,” out of that union, a third, new possibility will emerge. For example, if “butch” and “fem” polarities come together in alchemical union, a third possibility can emerge called “gender fluid” which moves things forward.

In practical terms, if you have been paying attention, the LGBTQ community in L.A., and everywhere else, under Elite Capture is badly fragmented by elite verticalization, aided and abetted by a revolution in human communication with everything that implies.

At the present historical moment, more LGBTQ community “either/or” thinking—either grassroots-based or elite-based—will just produce more division ad infinitum. A way of resolving this tension and division is by a radically reconceptualized model of current gay community organization, that originated in the early 1970s and served LGBTQ people well, with a new forward moving “both/and” model and methodology with present conditions in mind.

Albert Einstein

Albert Einstein (1879-1955): Do the Impossible (Portrait by Ferdinand Schmutzer, 1921)

So, how is that accomplished? I usually follow Albert Einstein’s admonition, “Always plan to do the impossible.” And here are some suggested elements of that “impossible” possibility.

1. A Truly Community Wide Coalition. Such a coalition would represent all sectors and strata of the community so it looked like Los Angeles—classes, races, genders, generations, regions and so forth. It would formulate a fair method of representation and simple written and agreed upon guardrails for its operation. It would develop a clear and effective “An Agenda for Community Action” incorporating community-felt needs that would represent all sectors and strata of the LGBTQ community. It would assertively, militantly if necessary, advocate for those needs and advances as a united, active, participatory community.

2. Larger and Transego Awareness: Enough core individuals would need to be in leadership roles so a new, larger concept of community could be born. An awareness would be fostered at all times that there is a goal involved that is transego—something much larger that involves the well-being of a newly emergent community consciousness and likewise making the organizing safe for individual differences of awareness—again, “both/and” thinking in the same bed.

3. The Necessity for Vision Carriers: In the way of our ancestors, there was an understanding that we all come into this world laden with gifts and that all those gifts are needed for the healthy survival of the village or the tribe. One of those roles is that of the Vision Carrier, like Wovoka whose vision of the Ghost Dance united First Nation people, colonizers, and others across the North

American plains in the late 19th century, posing a threat to the political establishment then. Vision Carriers are necessary because people forget who they are, why they are here, and what is possible. In the suggested Coalition, Vision Carriers will be essential to keep reminding people what they are doing and why they are doing it. There are many distractions these days. The presence of Vision Carriers is critical and essential.

4. Cooperation, Not Competition. It will be important that an attitude of cooperation—common effort—become the cornerstone of the suggested Coalition. A keen eye by all must be kept on centrifugal shadow energies that are always present to pull any effort apart. Those tendencies need to be identified and brought into group awareness before becoming destructive. People will always come and go, hopefully with group blessings. Avoid consensus decision making—total agreement—because contemporary egocentric society is poorly equipped to handle such a soul-based methodology. Make sure all voices are heard and that individual differences are respected. A young gay man growing up in Boyle Heights will have a world view different from that of his age peer in Brentwood. Cross-cultural, cross-generational, cross-racial, cross-ethnic, cross-class, cross-gender differences require deep listening, understanding and respect.

5. Simultaneous Acculturation and Enculturation. As the above Coalition begins to become a vehicle for the revisioning of the Los Angeles LGBTQ community, there would be an understanding that two very important historical and cultural processes are occurring simultaneously—“both/and”—acculturation and enculturation. The term “acculturation” refers to a new or minority culture adapting to a dominant culture. In can be done two ways—assimilation or integration—processes that can get confused very easily.

James Baldwin’s words define assimilation succinctly: “When a minority assimilates into the dominant culture it does so entirely on the terms of the dominant culture.” Avoid “the melting pot” shuck and jive because identity politics disappear and the same, old power structure remains in place. Implicit in gay assimilation is the disappearance of gay community and identity. Assimilation is the dominant political ideology in the gay community today.

Ideally, “integration” would imply a pluralistic society in which all groups work cooperatively with each other as equals and show mutual respect for each other’s differences without losing their own group identity.

August Wilson

August Wilson (1945-2005): Black Enculturation

Assimilation is to be avoided; integration to be encouraged; proceed cautiously.

The term “enculturation” refers to a minority group or individual cultivating, independent of the dominant culture, a deepening respect for autochthonous history and culture. It is cultural development within the LGBTQ community that evolves from gay history and the cultural arts that totally reflect gay culture, independent of the dominant culture. It’s what August Wilson and his 20th century plays mean for Black enculturation.

Another highly respected model would be what the Japanese-American community has done to create an enculturated arts center in Los Angeles’ Little Tokyo with the creation of the Japanese-American Theater, the East-West Players (who have fed my European-American soul numerous times since the early 1970s), Buddhist temples, and the powerful Japanese-American Museum.

The suggested Coalition, aware that the LGBTQ community is currently one-sided in the direction of acculturation, would play a catalytic role in gay enculturation with the possible creation of a LGBTQ Cultural and Performing Arts Center in L.A. as well as a Community Museum.

6. Consciousness Raising for a New Era. Recently, I dialogued with a young gay man who had just been called a gay hate word during astroll in his neighborhood, but he didn’t feel he was oppressed as a gay man. On the other hand, I asked a bunch of queer high school students how they felt oppressed, and it tumbled out of them intelligently for an hour.

The consciousness raising groups that grew out of and helped shape the Gay Liberation movement are inadequate for the content of queer oppression experienced today, however, it is a methodology that is valuable for what’s ahead. Using today’s experiences of hetero supremacy, a new model of such a group, without being monetized, needs to be developed using current language and tools.

Such a consciousness raising modality should have a widely disseminated point-of-entry contact, limited to 8-12 sessions, develop its own session to session materials on how to do such a group, be in person if possible, and feed that enlarged political consciousness into the new model of community organizing.

It’s all possible. Your involvement will change and reorient your queer lives forever.

In Closing

Given the history of violence of many kinds over millennia, even genocide, against gay people continuing into the 21st century almost everywhere, one fact needs to be indelibly etched onto the minds and hearts of LGBTQ people. The fact that there is a visible, organized, self-respecting, and vital gay community existing for 55 years in Los Angeles is a miracle of historic importance. Tend to it with care and respect.

Che Guevara once confessed (and his words hung next to my bed during the 1970s), “Let me say, at the risk of sounding ridiculous, revolutionaries are motivated by feelings of love.” And, love, community, a larger, self-generated understanding of who gay-lesbian-trans-queer people are, and engaged action will move all of us constructively forward beyond Elite Capture. Forward!