Gay Acceptance

Save LGBTQ Afghans

February 23, 2023

“Whoever saves one life saves the world entire.”
– The Talmud

At this very moment, gay genocide is happening in Afghanistan, genocide as defined by the United Nations. It is underreported by print and social media everywhere and has little activist traction. A humanitarian catastrophe is occurring that must have the attention of Western governments and all LGBTQ people and their allies.

In August 2021, the Taliban took control of Kabul, the capital of Afghanistan, which was soon followed by subjugation of the entire country. For LGBTQ people, pre-Taliban conditions were treacherous and dangerous, a country where hetero supremacy and its compulsory norms were firmly enforced and controlled through a very conservative culture and Islamic religion.

Since the Taliban takeover, LGBTQ lives have been dehumanized and terrorized by honor killings, torture, sexual violence in the form of rape, and legal and extralegal executions—more about this later. This gay genocide, coordinated countrywide, often has forced recognizable or outed gay men, lesbians, and trans women and men to go into solitary hiding to survive. Their only hope to avoid torture and dodge the bullet has been to flee the country. Yet, they have very few options to escape.

A little simple math reveals the magnitude of this crisis. While precise demographic statistics are unknown, the population of Afghanistan is reported to be 37 million people. About 40% is between 14-35-years old. Of that number, perhaps 10% (a percentage often used in estimating this LGBTQ demographic), or over a million, are LGBTQ people, the primary target population of the Taliban.

Despite this peril, teenagers and 20-somethings in Afghanistan have been influenced by the Gay Liberation movement via cell phones and the internet. They know about Stonewall, Pride celebrations, same-sex marriage, posting videos on Instagram and Tic Tok, Grindr, and queer culture. They state their preferred pronouns. They also know that survival might be possible if they can escape Afghanistan and reach a friendly country.

While any LGBTQ person’s life in hetero-male-centric Afghanistan can be in jeopardy somehow, it is young gay men who are targeted the most. After the Taliban takes them away, they are never seen again. Lesbians also have been killed, but they are often beaten into submission and forced into arranged hetero marriages. Women in general have much less unsupervised, private time within the home, making use of the cell phone and internet dangerous, and they must always be accompanied in public by a male relative. Trans people are also beaten viciously and suffer sexual violence. If it is a homosexual trans person, they are punished with death; if it is a heterosexual trans male or female, they might also be beaten, however, they are warned to return to their village of origin and conform to traditional gender norms.

As reported in Rainbow Railroad’s “No Way Out” research report, here are the desperate words of one young gay Afghan in hiding:

“The Taliban has taken over, they are abducting suspected gays, and you never see them again. Because of the way I talk and behave, it’s not hard to spot me.It’s hard for me to walk around now. Before the Taliban, I was just alone, and lonely, at least my life was not in danger. I have no hope. I have almost given up. Sometimes I have the urge to go public about it, with a pride flag in my hand, and scream as I walk through the streets of Kabul, ‘I am Gay.’ If my family finds out they would be the ones to kill me, no need of Taliban.” (From “No Safe Way Out,” a report by Rainbow Railroad)

The Last To Be Evacuated, The First To Be Executed

Since the Taliban takeover, Western countries have failed to prioritize the evacuation and resettlement of queer Afghans in addition to feminist leaders and human rights defenders. Over 150, 000 Afghans have been evacuated to Western countries since 2021, but it is estimated less than 1% were self-identified LGBTQ people.

This inaction might reflect the international community’s fatigue about Afghanistan. It is likely that latent and blatant hetero supremacy also plays a role—"if you are going to save anyone, it should be families.” Only Canada and Germany have made meaningful efforts to resettle LGBTQ Afghans. The U.S record is dismal.

Let me be frank with you. The response of LGBTQ people living in freedom to the gay genocide in Afghanistan has been sluggish at best, perhaps even shameful

Myopically, Western LGBTQ leaders and organization have ignored the plight of queer Afghans because they do not represent a key constituency or a political priority in their country. They have not demanded refugee slots from their governments for LGBTQ Afghans. Ethnocentrism enters the picture. Queer Afghans are out of sight and somebody else’s problem.

If you want to get a firsthand feeling of the suffering of these people, just go to Twitter and search the hashtags: #LetUsLive, #TheseAreMyLastWords, and #WeAreAfghanLGBTQ. Every day, more and more Afghans are being detained, disappearing, tortured, and murdered. It is quiet but real genocide.

Once more, “Silence” by liberated LGBTQ people = “Death” for young LGBTQ Afghans.

People and Organizations Helping LGBTQ Afghans Escape

Amid the general apathy of the LGBTQ community, there are righteous gay men and organizations that you need to know about as conscious and engaged queer people and valued allies. Unlike the short-lived marketers of low-level entertainment, they are your real LGBTQ influencers.

Michael Failla of Seattle

Michael Failla of Seattle

Michael Failla, 70, of Seattle has rescued and resettled about 80 LGBTQ people in the United States and other countries prior to the Afghan conflict. He has been involved in helping more than 100 Afghans escape and is helping dozens still in hiding in Afghanistan.

His diligent and relentless work was highlighted in the heart-warming and Emmy-winning documentary film “Out of Iraq”—the love story of two gay Iraqi soldiers who fell in love and for whom Michael spent years working to unite them again in Seattle where they were married.

In October 2021, after the American and European military occupation ended, some of Michael’s contacts gave him 19 seats on an evacuation flight to get LGBTQ people out of Afghanistan. He had to make a Solomonic decision about whose lives were to be saved. Anguishing sleeplessly over his answer, finally, 19 nonbinary gay men were selected because they were the most visible and likely to be arrested and executed by the Taliban.

Urgently, Michael needs volunteers to assist with his rescue and resettlement efforts: Canadians who would consider becoming a private sponsor and psychology professionals willing to counsel torture victims or people suffering from PTSD or advising and encouraging young people caught in a nightmare.

Volunteers can also help keep-up the morale, mood, and hope, and prevent suicide of escaping young LGBTQ Afghans by keeping in contact with them by cell phone during their arduous and dangerous road to freedom. This would be perfect gay eldering work for older people or anyone with some free time on their hands.

To help Michael’s rescue work or support it financially, contact him at mfailla@aol.com. Read: How a Seattle Man Became a Lifeline For Persecuted LGBTQ People in Other Countries

Frank and Joe

Frank, 57, (left) of Los Angeles and Joe, 62, of San Francisco

Joe, 62, of San Francisco, and his younger brother Frank, 57, of Los Angeles (their last names have been redacted so as not to endanger their rescue work), have started a rescue effort called Freedom Connection USA, a volunteer effort that rescues and resettles a few LGBTQ Afghan refugee at a time.

They had no experience doing this kind of work and did not know much about Afghan culture. Through trial-and-error learning over eighteen months, they mastered how to work through underground systems, sneaking at-risk, young LGBTQ people, women leaders, and human rights activists out of Afghanistan and housing them until they were assigned refugee status and resettled.

Recently, I was interviewing one of the young gay Afghans whose escape Joe and Frank had narrowly engineered with the Taliban in hot pursuit. Near the end of our talk, he burst into tears, sobbing uncontrollably as he choked out the words, “I wouldn’t be alive today if it weren’t for Joe.”

To get involved, contact FreedomConnectionUSA@gmail.com. Also consider financially supporting their work here: Support Women, LGBT Refugees in Getting to Safety

Rainbow Railroad staff in Canada

Rainbow Railroad staff in Canada

Rainbow Railroad is a well-known, nongovernmental organization anchored in Canada, with an excellent, dedicated staff. The group is modeled after the American “Underground Railroad” that smuggled slaves out of the South to safety and freedom in the North and Canada before the U.S. Civil War. They have been rescuing hundreds of queer people since 2006 in intolerant and dangerous countries, including a recent focus on Afghanistan and Ukraine.

Rainbow Railroad works with friendly Western governments willing to accept LGBTQ refugees and gets them resettled to safety as quickly as possible. Because of the delicate nature of their work with skittish Western officials, they cannot rock the boat too much, but they are very effective. Hopefully, the group will become a template for organizations in other countries to do lifesaving work.

In 2022, this NGO brought 220 Afghans to Western countries. Recently, Rainbow Railroad announced the resettlement of 600 more LGBTQ Afghan refugee in Canada. However, the current effort is minuscule compared to the gigantic need. It has 6,000 requests for help. CBS’ “60 Minutes” reported on their incredible work: 60 Minutes: Rainbow Railroad

And, of course, there are resettled LGBTQ Afghans heavily involved in this rescue work. Their names and efforts cannot be revealed because of the danger that would pose to their families, friends, and lovers in Afghanistan and reveal their methods.

Just as I was finishing this article, I received an e-mail telling me that M., with the help of American gay men, had just made it out of Afghanistan safely. M. is a 21-year-old gay man who has a university degree in computer science and speaks five languages. He has been bullied all his life because he does not meet the masculine expectations of traditional, hetero manhood. He is smart and resilient. As he was departing, his father blessed him by saying he was proud of him, bringing M. to tears. He will be resettled in Canada. There are many like M. They need your help.

Understanding LGBTQ Genocide in Afghanistan

Wherever enforced hetero supremacy has ruled in the world, past and present, gay life and culture have been hidden and secret. Some LGBTQ Afghans are given away by their natural, queer body language, speech, and behavior; most are apprehended by betrayal or accusations by their families, neighbors, friends and colleagues, even former boyfriends.

Particularly dangerous to their survival are video posts on You Tube, Tic- Tok, Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook that reveal their identity. The Taliban has many armed checkpoints on roads across the country where cell phones are seized and searched for evidence of e-mails, photos or videos that might incriminate a queer person. The Taliban has done house-to-house searches and broken-down doors to homes searching for gay prey.

There are three major avenues for exterminating LGBTQ people in Afghanistan—honor killings, legal and extralegal executions, and suicide.

It is common law practice in Afghanistan that any family can kill a member if that person brings shame upon the family, a consensus decision made by hetero, male family members: father, uncle, brother, cousin. Honor killings are used as punishment of men and women for refusing an arranged marriage, adultery, and when the family is shamed by discovering it has a gay, lesbian, or trans person in the family. The family has the right to kill that gay person with little or no consequence. An LGBTQ person could even be tracked down and killed in a foreign country to restore honor to a family. Here is a report from Human Rights Watch:

“In the months before the Taliban takeover, Brushna was living with her uncle’s family in a small village. One day in July 2021, six weeks before the fall of Kabul, her cousin discovered Brushna with her female partner and reported them to Brushna’s uncle. Her uncle wanted to kill her, Brushna said, to ‘get rid of this shame’ from the family. Brushna managed to escape and returned to her parent’s house in the city. Her uncle and male cousins demanded she be killed. Her parents quickly engaged her to a man who didn’t know she was a lesbian. … But her uncle and male cousins weren’t satisfied. ‘Why did you engage this daughter of yours? She needs to be killed,’ she overheard one of her relatives say. As long as the previous government was in power, she wasn’t too worried about these threats. ‘At that time there was no Taliban—there were police,’ Brushna said. ‘No one could kill me easily.’ But when the government fell in August, her uncle and male cousins joined the Taliban. Now they insisted, they had the power to kill Brushna if her father would not take action. ‘If you are not going to do it, we will do it,’ she recalled a relative saying. ‘We have the authority.’”

Brushna’s parents quickly had her married, beating her when she didn’t want to go through with it, and paid her husband to take her to another country under the pretense of finding a better job.

“But one of her uncle’s sons also emigrated to the same country, and got word to the husband that she is a lesbian. Now, Brushna says, her husband beats her every day and will not allow her to leave the house. ‘I’m afraid he will kill me or my uncle’s son will kill me,’ Brushna said. (From Human Rights Watch’s report “If You Fly to the Skies, We’ll Find You”)

In the lethal ways of hetero supremacy everywhere, Islam uses the Arabic term “fitrah” to describe what is “natural human disposition”—natural = heterosexual—and LGBTQ people are labeled unnatural, inferior beings that bring shame on a family and Islamic nations and, either overtly or covertly, they should be exterminated like vermin.

This Islamic intellectual genocide is like the official hetero supremacist dogma of the Catholic Church, and other religious groups, that propagandizes that LGBTQ people are “objectively morally disordered” (unnatural and inferior) and, as a punishment, they “will burn for all eternity in Hell”—in both Islamic and Christian countries providing the same ideological and religious justification for physical genocide.

A second road to LGBTQ extermination is through legal and extralegal executions. Legal and moral authority in Islam is based on three pillars— Qur’an, hadith, and sharia.

  • Qur’an, the Muslim holy book, says nothing about lesbians or trans people, but alludes to the sinfulness of male homosexuality in Sodom and Gomorrah, becoming the foundation on which the religious authority for death for homosexuals is based.
  • Hadith refers to prophet Mohammed’s sayings and actions during his lifetime. Basically, homosexuals should be stoned to death and, as for trans people, “turn them out of your house.”
  • Sharia, codified Islamic law over the centuries, dictates death to homosexuals (males and, by extrapolation, females) and the methodology for doing so. In Afghanistan, sometimes these executions are public, but the Taliban generally does it privately in a prison—out of sight, out of mind.

Recently, I viewed a several-minutes-long video montage of young gay men being executed in Muslim countries practicing sharia like Afghanistan—one hanging from a bridge with a noose around his neck, another being stoned to death by a frenzied mob, another being beheaded, and several being bound and thrown off tall buildings as bystanders rejoiced—gay hyper-reality. A searing, dharmic anger welled-up in me as I witnessed their executions; an anger that I had not experienced since the early days of Gay Liberation 50 years ago.

Extralegal extermination refers to vigilante mob justice outside the sharia courts that happens often in the countryside and sometimes in urban centers (25% of Afghanistan is urban). In either location, the result is a dead gay man, lesbian, or homosexual trans person.

There is a third road to extermination. When isolation, despair, and hopelessness engulf a young LGBTQ person in Afghanistan today, self-deliverance—suicide—can be a way to escape the genocide. It happens often. Recently, it was reported to me that the Taliban had jailed the beloved father and younger brother of a young gay man. He knew they had been arrested so that he would turn himself in to the Taliban in return for their release, which meant his certain death by the Taliban. So, he took his own life instead.

And there are other ways LGBTQ people in Afghanistan are dehumanized, hunted down, and eliminated. In this genocidal environment, no one can be trusted. Many are currying favor with the Taliban. To survive, visible LGBTQ people have gone into solitary hiding so they cannot be found and killed. This means they have lost their jobs and income, their ability to buy and secure food, their access to medical care, and they dare not to be seen in public in fear for their lives. One gay man in hiding reported he lives on one-handful of rice a day.

“A young gay man said that after the Taliban took over, he went shopping at the market when members of the Taliban noticed that he appeared different from others. They beat him in front of a crowd, injuring him. After that he hid in a basement and friends brought him food so he would not have to go out anymore.” (“No Safe Way Out”)

A Call To Moral Conscience and Engaged Action

(No Lame Excuses About Compassion Fatigue)

There is a heroic task staring the national and international LGBTQ community, along with its beloved allies, right in the face—the evacuation of all at-risk LGBTQ people from Afghanistan. The LGBTQ community must speak-out about and organize around this gay genocide. It is a moral imperative. It is an EMERGENCY.

While this activation involves all people of all ages with an engaged conscience, there is a special call to the Millennial and Gen Z generations because this challenge could be one of their defining legacies. They have the skills, energy, and unlimited, fresh imagination to spark such an effort.

In my half-century career as a gay community organizer, I always accompanied any discussion of a problem with possible proactive solutions. Here are a few suggestions:

Michael Failla, Freedom Connection USA, and Rainbow Railroad. There should be “Friends of Michael Failla,” “Friends of Freedom Connection USA,” “Friends of Rainbow Railroad,” and “Friends of ‘Save LGBTQ Afghans’” everywhere (the last organization yet to be organized by you and your LGBTQ community).

Organize! Grassroots Organize! Proactively Organize a broad-based, grassroots national and international coalition to raise consciousness about the life-or-death struggle of LGBTQ Afghans. Confront governments (particularly U.S.) to provide more LGBTQ refugees a home and lobby the United Nations for more LGBTQ refugee slots. Unleash the drive and fecundity of youth and consult with elders. There is a natural bond between young people and elders—together they are dynamite as societal change agents.

  • Send information packets to all elected officials (local, state, national) and follow-up with a phone call and e-mail requesting support. My Congressman, Adam Schiff, has already received such a packet.
  • University, college, high school LGBTQ groups and their teachers: This is a perfect issue for you.
  • Retired LGBTQ journalists and film/video makers: You are critically needed.
  • In Los Angeles, the LA LGBT Center might use a quarter of the proceeds from its annual dinner to save LGBTQ Afghans. The Gay Men’s Chorus of L.A., and other such choruses worldwide, could hold fund-raising concerts in Walt Disney Concert Hall directed towards saving young Afghan.
  • For those close to Harry Styles, Beyonce, Billy Eilish and others: How about a benefit concert to show respect and appreciation of their huge, young LGBTQ fan bases.
  • The possibilities are endless. A resourceful few-hours-a-week in collaboration with others, grounded and focused on this crisis, will move mountains.
  • Model your grassroots organizing on the success of Gay Liberation Fronts and ACT UP—centralized national coordination and clearinghouse, but decentralized activist groups with local decision-making.

Another highly successful and righteous model to find out about is the 1970’s Save Soviet Jews movement. Some of the young people who were central to those efforts are still around. Pick their brains. Get them involved.

It’s time to hear the cries for help from Afghanistan. It’s time for every sector and strata of the LGBTQ community to unite around this issue—saving young LGBTQ Afghans’ lives. As Existentialism teaches us, who you are is determined by what you do.